Return Home

Glenn Gould In Rapture

Thursday, September 04, 2014 - 07:00 AM

Brilliant Canadian pianist Glenn Gould as a young man, singing as he plays piano at a Steinway warehouse before choosing one for his recording session at Columbia Recording studios.
Gordon Parks/The LIFE Picture Collection/Getty Images

What's going on here, I can only guess, but here's what you're about to see: In the video below, the great musician Glenn Gould, supreme interpreter of Bach, is sitting at his living room piano on a low, low chair, his nose close to the keys. He's at his Canadian country house in his bathrobe.

Through the window, you catch snatches of his back yard. It's a windy day and he's got a coffee cup sitting on the piano top. He's working on a Bach partita, not just playing it, but singing along in his swinging baritone. As he plays, he gets so totally, totally lost in the music that suddenly (1:57 from the top), smack in the middle of a passage, with no warning, for no apparent reason, his left hand flips up, touches his head; he stands up, and walks in what looks like a trance to the window. There's an eerie silence. Then, in the quiet, you hear the Bach leaking out of him. He's still playing it, but in his head, he's scatting the beats. Then he turns, wanders back, sits down, and his fingers pick up right where his voice left off, but now with new energy, like he's found a switch and switched it.

What just happened? I'm not sure. But I think this is a rare vision of what it's like to be so in your head you leave your body, or at least the moving parts of your body, totally behind. There is a name for this, from psychologist Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi, but first, just watch. And don't miss the walk-to-the-window part ...


Glenn Gould was a complicated man. He didn't like to practice; instead he'd prepare for concerts mentally, running the piece over and over, playing with imaginary fingers. When he was a little baby, it was said that instead of crying, he would hum. He had perfect pitch and could read music before he could read words. So perhaps what you see in this video is just — for him — his way of "playing." He could switch seamlessly from fingering the piano to a purely virtual music-making; he could move fluently from real to not. Or maybe what we see him doing is something we all can do — but geniuses get there more often — reach a state of total absorption. Gould in his living room, for some reason, reminds me of Michael Jordan playing basketball or Etta James singing the blues; there's a concentration, a zoning in, that's so deep it feels special, like a kind of ecstasy.

The 'Flow State'

Athletes, of course, call this "being in the zone." Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi (pronounced MEE-high, CHEECH-sent-mee-high) calls it "the flow state." When you are in it, writes neuroscientist Daniel Levitin, "attention is focused on a limited perceptual field that receives your full concentration and complete investment. Action and awareness merge."

You get so deeply into your head, you lose track of everything except what you're doing. There was a surgeon, Csikszentmihalyi says, who wasn't aware that the roof of his operating room had collapsed until he was done with the surgery. In this state, "what you thinkbecomes what you do," Levitin writes. We "get wonderfully, blissfully lost in an activity, losing all track of time, of ourselves, our problems."

How one gets there — that's still a mystery. Practice is important. Tenacity matters. Talent helps. When you find your "flow," your brain changes. Dopamine and noradrenaline kick in, GABA neurons get suppressed; sex, hunger, thirst matter less, you are free to play more deeply with stream-of-conscious associations; you are chemically released and can now roam far and wide. Yes, you have no idea where you are or how this is happening; but that it's happening must be one of the most wonderful experiences ever. When I watch Glenn Gould walking back to his piano, carried there by an 18th-century fugue, I see a man transported, a man not lost, but found, a man in a state of grace. If there is a heaven, Glenn Gould at that moment is very close.

Glenn Gould is playing bits and pieces of J.S. Bach's Partita #2. The scene was shot in 1959 when Gould was a young man. It comes from Bruno Monsaingeon's documentary The Art of the Piano, which features short profiles of many great 20th-century pianists. The discussion of flow states comes from Daniel J. Levitin's new book, The Organized Mind: Thinking Straight in the Age of Information Overload.


More in:

Comments [7]

John Schott from Berkeley, CA

I am a huge fan of Glenn Gould and, for that matter, Radiolab. This footage, as far as I recall is from an early CBC show. I would like to politely remind you that Gould was notoriously fond of planning things to seem spontaneous. Later in life he wrote out whole interviews which he then taped with music critics who were willing to "play along". I have no idea if this is the case here, but I don't think it can be ruled out. This, of course, in no way undermines the brilliance of his playing. But there was also a brilliance in his relationship with "truth" in media - witness his fanatically pieced together recordings from multiple takes.

Sep. 17 2014 08:28 PM
Sean from Georgia

Gould himself referred to this as the "ecstatic experience", and is eloquently discussed in Payzant's biography.

Here is another discussion on his vocalizing, "Much Ado About Humming":

Sep. 12 2014 06:35 PM
Chris from Central California

And who can forget Thelonious Monk ?

We just don't know if Bach himself hummed along, when he played the organ in his local church, writing a new Mass for every Sunday.

With electric guitar players, we can't hear them, unless they get closer to the microphone - Jimi Hendrix comes to mind.

With more modern and simpler folk, blues, pop and commercial music we find instrumentalist/singers who play and sing at the same time, having evolved what you can see Glen Gould doing in this video into what everybody understands today without getting offended or marvels at it.

Glen Gould is playing the 'lyrics and words' with his fingers and hums/sings along the melody he hears in his mind.

Sep. 12 2014 06:10 PM
Jacob from Pittsburgh

It seems incorrect to say this 1959 recording "comes from" Bruno Monsaingeon's documentary The Art of the Piano. Bruno Monsaingeon, being a teenager in 1959, did not shoot this footage. Where did this footage actually "come from" ?

Sep. 11 2014 11:04 AM
Nick from Canada

It reminds me of Keith Jarrett, he has the same demeanor including the humming. Here is a link to a YouTube video of him playing with Jack Dejohnette and Gary Peacock at about 5 minutes in you can see him fully in his zone! The result is brilliant and beautiful piano playing.

Sep. 05 2014 10:23 PM
Christian Davis from sheridan wy

The humming was part of an effort to achieve that "flow." It was a kind of bridge between what he heard in his head and what came out on the piano. Glenn Gould was self-absorbed as a musician, and didn't bother himself too much with what the audience's musical experience was.

Sep. 05 2014 06:48 PM

Every recording i have of Glenn Gould is masterfully played but incredibly frustrating to listen to because of that humming. Why do you suppose he felt it necessary to hum along all the time. Was that the result of some brain disorder?

Sep. 05 2014 01:42 PM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

Supported by